Mascara Review

My go to beauty item for sure…I often use multiple mascaras at the same time and now is no different. My routine is layering couple different kinds to get the look I want. Normally one that volumes and one that lengthens. Lately my go to has been Loreal Lash paradise but in my Boxy Charm I received It Cosmetics Superhero and I am liking it a lot. Honestly I have been hard pressed to have anything come close to Lash paradise, so now I have two favorites because they have different features. Price point is definitely my decision maker because I go through mascara like crazy. In this picture I have on both, left It and right Loreal. Can you tell the difference?

Review - Fave Mascara


Loreal - Lash Paradise under $10

  • Definitely gives me fullness and big lashes. I like the length, but it is not the best for lengthening that I have used. Brush is great, there can be clumping. No flaking, this wears really well and price point is unreal. YES VOTE!

It Cosmetics - Superhero $24

  • Fabulous and long. Brush is narrow and there is no clumping. Wears great and does not flake either. Of all mascaras at this price range I like this one the most these days. YES VOTE!

Other Mascara in my lineup


NYX Worth the Hype - under $6

  • Great for trendy colors. This is not a huge price commitment, so I sampled purple and brown. I love the brown for daytime, easy makeup look. Purple was unfortunately too light I could not really see it on. Layering it did not make lashes darker either. Brush is thin, no clumping issues and it does not flake on me. YES VOTE!

Loreal - YES VOTE! See above

Buxom Big tease - $22

  • Came back to this one after a while and it delivers big lashes. Brush is thick so tends to clump after some use. On me this one flakes so wearability is low score for me. NO VOTE!